Monday, May 22, 2006

Masterful Coaching by Robert Hargrove (2002)

In general coaching involves unleashing the human spirit and expanding people’s capacity to achieve new goals and to bring about real change.

Robert Hargrove goes a bit farer by defining a masterful coach as a person who is a vision builder and value shaper.


“Coaching is hot” and “Masterful Coaching (MC) is an idea whose time has come” are main slogans used by the author to get his message over. The topic of MC is based on four assertions why a leader has at first to be a coach and teacher to be successful:

  1. MC is based on inspiring people to realize an impossible future they can engage in
  2. MC involves personal and organizational reinvention
  3. MC provides a powerful, repeatable technology for producing breakthroughs for people and breakthrough results
  4. Masterful Coach is an extraordinary human being who combines wisdom, compassion, and a sense of humor

Further definitions for MC:

ü Listening for people’s greatness for bringing out the best in them

ü Grounded in expanding people’s capacity to achieve what they need to achieve

Hargrove clarifies four myths of coaching, created by a network of beliefs and assumptions by opening a way to create a new cultural clearing to support coaching.

Myth 1: Coaching is a last gasp effort for washouts

? Reality: Coaching is for winners who seek an edge or advantage

Myth 2: Coaching is about identifying and filling gaps

? Reality: Coaching is about creating futures, not just filling gaps

Myth 3: Coaching is about development for individuals

? Reality: Coaching integrates performance and development with people in groups

Myth 4: Coaching is an isolated event that happens at the yearly performance appraisal

? Reality: Coaching is a continuous, but not continual process

In addition the author gives some examples out of his experience to illustrate his results, for example he recognized that winners love living in the gaps, whereas losers love to pretend they do not exist. Another realization is that the best leaders in the world spend 40 to 50 % of their time coaching and teaching people in groups to produce personal and business breakthroughs.

If you want to know more about Masterful Coaches: read the book mentioned above!

Tuesday, May 16, 2006

Today I would like you to meet with concept of ADKAR. ADKAR is an acronym for a model used in Change management. It stands for Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement.

ADKAR is a goal-oriented change management model that allows change management teams to focus their activities on specific business results. The model was initially used as a tool for determining if change management activities like communications and training were having the desired results during organizational change. The model has its origins in aligning traditional change management activities to a given result or goal.

The goals or outcomes defined by ADKAR are sequential and cumulative. An individual must obtain each element in sequence in order for a change to be implemented and sustained.

As a manager, you can use this model to identify gaps in your change management process and to provide effective coaching for your employees. The ADKAR model can be used to:

  • diagnose employee resistance to change
  • help employees transition through the change process
  • create a successful action plan for personal and professional advancement during change
  • develop a change management plan for your employees

The ADKAR model has the ability to identify why changes are not working and help you take the necessary steps to make the change successful. You will be able to break down the change into parts, understand where the change is failing and address that impact point.

The ADKAR model was published by Prosci in 1998 after research with more than 300 companies undergoing major change projects. This model is intended to be a coaching tool to help employees through the change process.

To use the ADKAR model effectively, you will need to understand the underlying framework for change initiatives. In the diagram below, change happens on two dimensions: the business dimension (vertical axis) and the people dimension (horizontal axis). Successful change happens when both dimensions of change occur simultaneously.

Business dimension of change

The business dimension of change includes the typical project elements.

  • Business need or opportunity is identified.
  • Project is defined (scope and objectives).
  • Business solution is designed (new processes, systems and organizational structure).
  • New processes and systems are developed.
  • Solution is implemented into the organization.

These are the standard elements of a business change that managers feel most comfortable managing.

People dimension of change

Research shows that problems with the people dimension of change is the most commonly cited reason for project failures. In a study with 248 companies, effective change management with employees was listed as one of the top-three overall success factors for the project. Helping managers be effective sponsors of change was considered the most critical success factor overall.

Effective management of the people dimension of change requires managing five key goals that form the basis of the ADKAR model:

  • Awareness of the need to change
  • Desire to participate and support the change
  • Knowledge of how to change (and what the change looks like)
  • Ability to implement the change on a day-to-day basis
  • Reinforcement to keep the change in place
Top Five Insights - Best Practices
I have found interesting benchmark findings from report with 411 participants from 59 countries on Change management. The content below comes from the 2005 Best Practices in Change Management benchmarking report:

Participants were asked what they would do differently on their next project.Top 5 significant insights found are:


Dedicate resources to change management

The organizations have recognized the importance of a change management and they have started to dedicate the appropriate resources to make it a success. If you have control over resource allocation or the structure of work on the project, then you should make change management a priority.


Use of a methodology

Two years ago only 34% of participants used a formal model to manage change (as opposed to ad hoc activities), compared to 55% in the 2005 study.

No matter where the methodology comes from (externally provided or internally developed), the change agents have the need to work with some structure around how to manage the human side of change.


Reasons for resistance

Participants cited several reasons for resistance and they are different for front line employees and managers. They are very interesting to me so I leave them with their full explanation:

Primary reasons why front line employees resist change

  1. Employees were not aware of the business need for change. Employees did not understand why a change was being made nor did they understand how the change would impact them (WIIFM - what's in it for me).
  2. Lay-offs were announced or feared as part of the change. Employees were concerned at the prospect of being unemployed.
  3. Employees were unsure if they had the skills needed for success in the future state. Employees were concerned about new responsibilities, changing technologies and whether they would be able perform well under a new performance measurement system.
  4. Individuals were comfortable with the current state. Employees wanted to maintain the personal rewards and sense of accomplishment and fulfillment provided by the status quo.
  5. Employees believed they were being asked to do more with less, or do more for the same pay.

Primary reasons managers resist change

  1. Loss of power and control. Managers perceived change as having a negative impact on their span of control and on their careers.
  2. Overloaded with current responsibilities. Managers already had many demanding responsibilities and the change created one more thing to manage. In some cases there was already too much change going on in the organization.
  3. Lacked awareness of the need for change. Managers did not understand the business need for change or the risks of not changing.
  4. Lacked the required skills. Some managers did not have the skills to manage change or employee resistance. Other managers lacked the skills required to succeed in their new roles. They resisted because they felt unprepared to manage the change.
  5. Fear, uncertainty and doubt. Managers lacked clarity surrounding the change. They were skeptical about the change or fearful and uncertain about the future state.

Teams can take actions to mitigate many of the reasons for resistance. Proactively identifying potential resistance and its causes can help teams build buy-in early on and minimize resistance as the change is introduced. The list above can be used as a starting point to develop proactive measures to these issues.


Biggest obstacle: resistance

The biggest obstacle remains the same since survey in 2003: Resistance from employees and middle management. What does it means?


Resistance must be expected and planned. With effective change management, it can be prevented, overcomed and mitigated. It must be understood to be fight against. The top reasons for resistance were given in the previous paragraph.


Greatest contributor: sponsorship

Participants were asked to identify their greatest contributor to overall project success. Number one greatest contributor was: Active and visible sponsorship.

The conclusion is that as change agent, you need to make sure your sponsors understand how important their involvement is and what effective sponsorship looks like. Teams must act as enablers to ensure that sponsors are executing and sending the 'right' messages.


So what we should learn from this survey is: Plan resources not only for your project, but also to the managment of change that will be need to happen. Make the sponsor involved therefore active and visible. Prepare proactively for the coming resistance and respect it.

Thursday, May 04, 2006

Change Management – what is it about?

As a first step we would like to give you a basic idea about Change Management within Business Process Reengineering.

Change Management is a process of developing a planned approach to change in an organization with the objective to maximize the collective efforts of all people involved in the change. In short you can say that Change Management deals with how people are being affected by an organizational change.

In the literature exist two types of Change Management, reactive and proactive. The former one contains an internal source of change (management responds to change in macroenvironment), whereas the later one concerns the external source of change (management initiates change to achieve desired goals).

To be effective Change Management should be multi-disciplinary, that means it should touch all aspects of an organization. Primarily it is a human resource issue and the management’s responsibility is to detect trends in the macroenvironment, be able to identify changes, initiate programs and estimate the impact of change on employee behavior patterns, work processes and motivation.

A change program should contain several issues:

§ Describe change process, explain reasons why by using complete and transparent information

§ Designed to effectively implementation, aligned with organizational objectives, environmental trends and perceptions of employees

§ Provide support to employees, involve them directly in process

Management should focus on tow main tasks to implement successfully a change:

§ Creating readiness for change

§ Overcoming resistance to change

Therefore six categories of Change Management approaches can be defined:

  1. Individual Change Approaches

= focus on the impact change has on the individual worker

  1. Social Psychological Change Approaches

= based on the work of Kurt Lewin who’s basic idea was that the individual person is more shaped by her social environment than by her genes

  1. Cultural Change Approaches

= change form the perspective of the organizational culture: Culture is mostly unconscious and therefore able to control the behaviors of organizational change

  1. Innovation Approaches

= change from the perspective of the diffusion of a new idea or practice

  1. Global Change Approaches

= focus on global transformations, based on life-threatening changes happening in an organization’s environment

  1. Practitioner Approaches to Change

= theoretical approach is combined with practical experiences

We hope now having attracted your attention for this special topic of Business Process Reengineering, which will be continued.