Tuesday, May 16, 2006

Top Five Insights - Best Practices
I have found interesting benchmark findings from report with 411 participants from 59 countries on Change management. The content below comes from the 2005 Best Practices in Change Management benchmarking report:

Participants were asked what they would do differently on their next project.Top 5 significant insights found are:


Dedicate resources to change management

The organizations have recognized the importance of a change management and they have started to dedicate the appropriate resources to make it a success. If you have control over resource allocation or the structure of work on the project, then you should make change management a priority.


Use of a methodology

Two years ago only 34% of participants used a formal model to manage change (as opposed to ad hoc activities), compared to 55% in the 2005 study.

No matter where the methodology comes from (externally provided or internally developed), the change agents have the need to work with some structure around how to manage the human side of change.


Reasons for resistance

Participants cited several reasons for resistance and they are different for front line employees and managers. They are very interesting to me so I leave them with their full explanation:

Primary reasons why front line employees resist change

  1. Employees were not aware of the business need for change. Employees did not understand why a change was being made nor did they understand how the change would impact them (WIIFM - what's in it for me).
  2. Lay-offs were announced or feared as part of the change. Employees were concerned at the prospect of being unemployed.
  3. Employees were unsure if they had the skills needed for success in the future state. Employees were concerned about new responsibilities, changing technologies and whether they would be able perform well under a new performance measurement system.
  4. Individuals were comfortable with the current state. Employees wanted to maintain the personal rewards and sense of accomplishment and fulfillment provided by the status quo.
  5. Employees believed they were being asked to do more with less, or do more for the same pay.

Primary reasons managers resist change

  1. Loss of power and control. Managers perceived change as having a negative impact on their span of control and on their careers.
  2. Overloaded with current responsibilities. Managers already had many demanding responsibilities and the change created one more thing to manage. In some cases there was already too much change going on in the organization.
  3. Lacked awareness of the need for change. Managers did not understand the business need for change or the risks of not changing.
  4. Lacked the required skills. Some managers did not have the skills to manage change or employee resistance. Other managers lacked the skills required to succeed in their new roles. They resisted because they felt unprepared to manage the change.
  5. Fear, uncertainty and doubt. Managers lacked clarity surrounding the change. They were skeptical about the change or fearful and uncertain about the future state.

Teams can take actions to mitigate many of the reasons for resistance. Proactively identifying potential resistance and its causes can help teams build buy-in early on and minimize resistance as the change is introduced. The list above can be used as a starting point to develop proactive measures to these issues.


Biggest obstacle: resistance

The biggest obstacle remains the same since survey in 2003: Resistance from employees and middle management. What does it means?


Resistance must be expected and planned. With effective change management, it can be prevented, overcomed and mitigated. It must be understood to be fight against. The top reasons for resistance were given in the previous paragraph.


Greatest contributor: sponsorship

Participants were asked to identify their greatest contributor to overall project success. Number one greatest contributor was: Active and visible sponsorship.

The conclusion is that as change agent, you need to make sure your sponsors understand how important their involvement is and what effective sponsorship looks like. Teams must act as enablers to ensure that sponsors are executing and sending the 'right' messages.


So what we should learn from this survey is: Plan resources not only for your project, but also to the managment of change that will be need to happen. Make the sponsor involved therefore active and visible. Prepare proactively for the coming resistance and respect it.